Thursday, January 22, 2009

The "Untimely" Cause (Week 4)

Let’s recap what I have asserted thus far:
Truth is absolute
Reason is our greatest tool for understanding truth.
Our universe (that which is composed of matter, energy, space, and time) had a beginning.

THE LAND BEFORE TIME

The beginning of our universe has been corroborated again and again by physical law (entropy), theory (Big Bang, General Relativity), and observation (universal expansion, cosmic background radiation, etc). Outside of an intense want for an eternal universe, there is little reason to doubt such a beginning. So, we’re left with the seemingly unanswerable question: “what was before the universe”? My question to you is: Does such a question have any meaning?

The physical state of the universe is, at best, counterintuitive. I would imagine that when I assert that the universe is expanding, the vast majority would interpret it as “the universe is expanding into space”. Physics tells us, however, that this is not the case. The universe does not exist in space; rather, space exists within the universe. This notion is further confirmed when we observe the far reaches of the universe. The expansion is accelerating because space itself is expanding. Moreover, time exists within the universe. Time itself is interrelated with space. It fits into relativity. Its very definition is dependent upon it being an aspect of our universe. We have no scientific reason to believe that time exists outside of our universe and if some sequential time-like thing did exist outside of our universe, we would be forced to give it a different name altogether since we have defined “time” as a quantity tied to the universe.

(Big breath)

What would it mean for something to exist “before” the universe if time is of the universe? Why would we presume that something existed “before” time? If something is within time, that something should also be within the universe. Does it not require significantly more faith to eschew science and to believe that there was time “before” the universe than it does to believe what observation and substantiated theory have shown? Unless we dismiss Einstein’s equations and corroborative evidence completely, are we not compelled to believe that time did not exist until the universe existed?

CAUSE AND EFFECT

All of science is built upon the search for a cause. Despite the truly marvelous analogy (and I mean this with all sincerity) given in the comments section of my last post where Skyhook used beta decay as a model for positing the existence of an uncaused physical phenomenon, in actuality the observation of this decay led directly to a quest to find the cause. Why? Because scientists know that all effects are caused. As was correctly pointed out, radioactive decay does have a cause at the subatomic level.

Back to the universe… all effects are caused so what caused the cause? The universe and indeed any conception of a time-inclusive cosmos must be susceptible to causality. Conversely, an entity that is not susceptible to causality must not carry with it the concept of time. I can say this with certainty because time is defined. (This is like saying that any continuous, two-dimensional shape whose points are equidistant from a single point is a circle. You can conceptualize a square, but since the points on a square are not equidistant from a single point, you cannot correctly call a square a circle… no big revelations here.) Scientists have theorized concepts such as anti-time or imaginary time, but such ideas do not free us from the effects of time (namely cause and effect) in the same way that squares do not preclude the existence of circles. As such, anything that is not susceptible to cause and effect must be eternal and anything eternal cannot be susceptible to cause and effect (after all, without time, cause and effect are meaningless).

I would assert that something existing outside of time is, by definition, eternal and uncaused.

Where has science and logic led us?
- Physical effects have a cause.
- The components of the universe came into being.
- Time is a component of the universe.
- Therefore time had a cause.
- The cause of time cannot exist in time.
- Therefore the cause of time must be eternal.

NOTE: This was once a much longer post with a whole section on mathematics and the concept of “infinity”, but I imagine this first piece (above) will be discussed rather heatedly; so, I will pick up the rest of the universe argument next week to allow the appropriate time for discussion. Plus, I don’t want to drive away all of my readers with math.