Thursday, January 15, 2009

Our Temporary Universe (Week 3)

While it is not necessary for the belief in a deity that the universe was born, once we have clearly illustrated that the universe is not eternal, it is extraordinarily difficult to reconcile the creation of the universe without a creator of the universe. Obviously this post is tracking toward a creator; however, this week I would like to focus on the more specific point that it is not reasonable to believe that the universe is eternal; therefore, it must have had a beginning.

GENERAL RELATIVITY

In the early part of the 20th century, Einstein proposed theories that were at best counterintuitive. Chief among them was his theory of General Relativity. General Relativity is a topic that is covered in graduate college courses over several semesters, so we obviously won’t be delving too deeply into the subject; however, we should take a look at some of the things predicted by this theory:
Space, time, matter, and energy are interrelated.
The universe should be expanding.
Space, time, matter, and energy (the components of the universe) had a beginning.

Einstein himself thought the consequences of his theory to be “irritating”. At the time he posited his theory, he was a pantheist (believer that the universe is an eternal God). So irritated was Einstein that he actually introduced his infamous “cosmological constant” into the general relativity equations. Later discovered to simply be bad mathematics, this constant would have nullified the aforementioned implications. Hubble (as in the telescope) was among the first to actually observe the “red shift” necessarily implied by an expanding universe. Still in disbelief, Einstein made the journey himself to look through Hubble’s telescope and verify his claim. Much to his chagrin, Einstein’s theory looks to be correct.

THE BIG BANG

The Big Bang Theory is the most widely accepted theory regarding the origin of the universe. It yields no answer to the philosophical questions like:
"Why are we here?"
"Is there a God?"
Rather, it is a theory based on the forensic evidence we have regarding the universe. Our measurements tell us that every massive object in the universe is moving away from a central point. The radiant energy we observe at the very edges of the universe is consistent with what we would expect from an explosion on the magnitude of the Big Bang. Everything points to the idea that all matter, energy, and space was located at a centralized point light years from our current position. In other words, all that comprises the universe exploded into being about 14 billion years ago.

For many years, many scientists did not view this as tantamount to saying that the universe was created. After all, the universe could just as easily slow its expansion and being to collapse upon itself. Then, matter and energy would rush in at somewhere around the speed of light until everything ended up at a single point once again. From there, the universe would simply bang again and the cycle would continue for eternity. In the last several decades, however, we have been able to more accurately see the physics of the universe's fringes. What astronomers have discovered is that the expansion of the universe is accelerating. What does this mean? Basically it means that the universe shows no signs of slowing down and reversing course and thus no sign of collapse (The "Big Crunch").

If the universe will continue to expand throughout its lifetime, logic tells us that it had a single starting point in time. In other words, the universe had a beginning.

COSMIC RADIATION

In 1965, two scientists at Bell Labs, Penzias and Wilson, won the Nobel Prize for their accidental discovery of cosmic background radiation. Previously unseen, such radiant energy must exist if the universe actually began with a bang. One of the leading 20th century physicists, Robert Jastrow described the discovery this way:
The measurements showed that the earth itself could not be the origin of this radiation, nor could the radiation come from the direction of the moon, the sun, or any other particular object in the sky. The entire Universe seemed to be the source. The two physicists were puzzled by their discovery. They were not thinking about the origin of the Universe, and they did not realize that they had stumbled upon the answer to one of the cosmic mysteries. Scientists who believed in the theory of the Big Bang had long asserted that the Universe must have resembled a white-hot fireball in the very moments after the Big Bang occurred. Gradually, as the Universe expanded and cooled, the fireball would have become less brilliant, but its radiation would have never disappeared entirely. It was the diffuse glow of this ancient radiation, dating back to the birth of the Universe, that Penzias and Wilson apparently discovered.

The Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) yielded data in 2008 that confirmed not only the existence of cosmic background radiation but also its predicted behavior (I’ll speak more to this in the next couple of posts). COBE left little doubt to the veracity of the Big Bang.

THOSE CRAZY LAWS OF THERMODYNAMICS

Let me pose a hypothetical question: If I have been shrinking for all eternity, how tall am I? Mathematically, the question actually has an answer. If I said that my height was H, the amount I shrank each year was X, and time was represented by t, my current height would be H/(H + Xt). Now, since I have been shrinking for eternity, t would approach infinity. So, the equation basically becomes H/(Z →∞) which is equal to zero. My current height would be zero. Interesting hypothetical, Randy, but why in the world do we care?

Thermodynamics is an aspect of physics that deals with the energy of a system. The Second Law of Thermodynamics concerns the notion of entropy. Entropy is somewhat difficult to describe in full without getting terribly mathematical; however, the basic idea of entropy is that any system with no external energy acting on it works toward equilibrium. If we look, for instance, at two pots of water - one near boiling and one just above freezing - what happens when we combine the two pots? They come to one temperature. The new pot is neither near boiling nor near freezing. If you then separate the water again, they maintain their equilibrium temperature. Neither returns to its original state. This is entropy in a nutshell. All systems come to equilibrium.

So, let’s compare our incredible shrinking Randy to entropy. If the universe (another system) were trending toward a state of equilibrium for eternity, where would the universe be? At equilibrium! What do we see instead? Stars burn at millions of degrees. The majority of space is right around -230 degrees within our solar system and closer to -273 degrees in the expanses between the stars. The universe is nowhere near the homogeneous state to which it is trending. Therefore it cannot have been trending for all eternity.

Physical laws and theories tell us that the universe had a beginning. Seemingly every new discovery serves to substantiate these physical laws and theories. At the end of the day, it would simply be unreasonable to believe in the eternal universe.

ASIDE: There are numerous other theories regarding the universe’s origins, though none of them generally considered credible for various reasons. I opted not to pick and choose which theories to discuss but I would be happy to explore any alternatives you might suggest in the Comments section.